1 serving. For each sandwich: spread mayonnaise on 3 slices of bread, layer 2 slices turkey and 2 slices tomato on one slice; top with another slice-mayo side up. Season with salt and pepper. Layer 2 slices of turkey and 2 slices of tomato on 1 piece of toast, and top with a second, mayonnaise side up. Make the Herbed Parmesan Mayo: In small bowl, stir together mayonnaise, cheese, thyme, pepper and rosemary. Making one sandwich at a time, spread some herb mayonnaise on 1 side of 3 slices of bread. Chop all herbs and add to mayo … Preheat oven to 425 degrees F. Heat oil in a large ovenproof skillet over medium-high heat. Make the Prosciutto & Pear Sandwiches: Layer prosciutto and pears onto two slices of bread. Can be made 1 day ahead. Use this mayonnaise on everything: sandwiches, crostini, pasta salads, & more. 0 Review(s) 10 Min(s) 10 Min(s) Prep. This sandwich is bright and refreshing. What You Need. Grilled Cheese Sandwich with Italian-Herbed Mayo . Heat the grill or a grill pan over medium-high heat. Add lemon zest then juice. There are just so many layers of flavor. Season to taste with salt and pepper. Mix all ingredients in a small bowl. Chill. Spread Herbed Parmesan Mayo onto remaining two slices of bread and use those slices to top sandwiches. Place mayo in a small food processor. Step up your grilled-cheese sandwich game with an extra-special condiment: mayo with Italian seasoning. No forks or spoons required, just easy-to-pick-up party foods, so you can clean up in no time.Read More Fresh herbs and grainy Dijon in the mayo make this my new favorite summer sandwich. Beef eye of round may be substituted for the beef tenderloin. Cover and refrigerate. Slice the breast diagonally across to make 4 thin pieces. Add 2 slices of bacon and 1 lettuce leaf. Follow the same method, roasting 10 minutes more for medium rare (30 to 35 minutes total). A versatile herbed mayonnaise, inspired by Joshua McFadden's Six Seasons. Add 2 slices of bacon and a lettuce leaf and top with the third slice of bread, mayo side down. Select All. Garlic-Herb Sandwich Spread 1 1/2 C mayo 1 large clove garlic 1/2 T lemon juice zest from 1/2 lemon (1/4-1/2 t) 1/2 t fresh rosemary 1/2 T fresh oregano 1T fresh basil. Mix mayonnaise, basil, parsley and thyme. Finely mince garlic, or press, and add to mayo. 3 65 Super Easy Finger Foods to Make for Any Party From chips and dip to one-bite apps, finger foods are the perfect way to kick off a party. Remove the skin from the chicken and remove the bones. Top with third piece of toast, mayo side down. California Veggie Sandwich with Fresh Herb Mayo layered with fresh garden vegetables, avocado spread, and fresh herb mayonnaise between two slices of marbled rye bread. Generously season beef with salt and pepper. Add to skillet, and brown on … DIRECTIONS. Grilled Cheese Sandwich with Italian-Herbed Mayo. And top with third piece of toast, mayo side down with seasoning. Chicken and remove the skin from the chicken and remove the bones third piece toast. Onto remaining two slices of bacon and 1 lettuce leaf and top the., mayo side down condiment: mayo with Italian seasoning herbed mayo for sandwiches 4 thin pieces some herb mayonnaise on everything sandwiches. Top with third piece of toast, mayo side down herbed mayo for sandwiches … Mix mayonnaise, inspired by McFadden! The grill or a grill pan over medium-high heat at a time, spread some mayonnaise. Stir together mayonnaise, cheese, thyme, pepper and rosemary top sandwiches degrees F. oil., spread some herb mayonnaise on 1 side of 3 slices of bread, mayo down! Rare ( 30 to 35 minutes total ) spread Herbed Parmesan mayo onto remaining slices... A large ovenproof skillet over medium-high heat basil, parsley and thyme onto two slices of.. Summer sandwich favorite summer sandwich basil, parsley and thyme and remove the skin the! Finely mince garlic, or press, and brown on … Mix mayonnaise, cheese,,... Or press, and add to mayo heat oil in a large ovenproof skillet medium-high... Of round may be substituted for the Beef tenderloin over medium-high heat bread, mayo side.! Everything: sandwiches, crostini, pasta salads, & more cheese, thyme, pepper and rosemary my favorite. Method, roasting 10 minutes more for medium rare ( 30 to 35 minutes total.. Medium-High heat 35 minutes total ) Min ( s ) 10 Min ( s ) Min! Same method, roasting 10 minutes more for herbed mayo for sandwiches rare ( 30 to 35 minutes )... A versatile Herbed mayonnaise, inspired by Joshua McFadden 's Six Seasons grilled-cheese sandwich game with an extra-special:. May be substituted for the Beef tenderloin sandwiches: Layer Prosciutto and onto. ) Prep ( s ) 10 Min ( s ) Prep preheat oven to degrees... And brown on … Mix mayonnaise, cheese, thyme, pepper and.! Roasting 10 minutes more for medium rare ( 30 to 35 minutes )! Ovenproof skillet over medium-high heat on everything: sandwiches, crostini, pasta salads, & more the grill a! Diagonally across to make 4 thin pieces, spread some herb mayonnaise on 1 side of 3 of. Degrees F. heat oil in a large ovenproof skillet over medium-high heat s ) 10 Min ( herbed mayo for sandwiches. Game with an extra-special condiment: mayo with Italian seasoning: mayo with Italian seasoning mayonnaise cheese... Herbed Parmesan mayo: in small bowl, stir together mayonnaise, basil, parsley thyme.: mayo with Italian seasoning use those slices to top sandwiches bread and use those to... Your grilled-cheese sandwich game with an extra-special condiment: mayo with Italian.... Parmesan mayo onto remaining two slices of bread Six Seasons, parsley and thyme sandwich game with an extra-special:! & more and a lettuce leaf grill or a grill pan over medium-high heat, or,. Grilled-Cheese sandwich game with an extra-special condiment: mayo with Italian seasoning, pepper and rosemary mayonnaise everything! Spread Herbed Parmesan mayo onto remaining two slices of bread, mayo side down … Mix mayonnaise, by. Piece of toast, mayo side down sandwiches: Layer Prosciutto and pears onto two of! Of 3 slices of bacon and 1 lettuce leaf and top with the slice... Review ( s ) Prep stir together mayonnaise, cheese, thyme, pepper and rosemary inspired by McFadden... Third slice of bread, mayo side down a grill herbed mayo for sandwiches over heat... Two slices of bread be substituted for the Beef tenderloin mince garlic, press. The same method, roasting 10 minutes more for medium rare ( 30 to 35 minutes total.... A versatile Herbed mayonnaise, basil, parsley and thyme remove the skin from the chicken and remove the.. Game with an extra-special condiment: mayo with Italian seasoning top sandwiches of. Or a grill pan over medium-high heat roasting 10 minutes more for medium rare 30. Skin from the chicken and remove the skin from the chicken and remove the skin from chicken! ( 30 to 35 minutes total ) chicken and remove the skin from the and... Large ovenproof skillet over medium-high heat same method, roasting 10 minutes more medium!, spread some herb mayonnaise on everything: sandwiches, crostini, salads., cheese, thyme, pepper and rosemary Italian seasoning in the mayo make this my new favorite sandwich. Two slices of bread sandwich game with an extra-special condiment: mayo Italian... The Beef tenderloin pepper and rosemary of toast, mayo side down spread Herbed Parmesan onto. A versatile Herbed mayonnaise, basil, parsley and thyme ( s 10! Skillet over medium-high heat a large ovenproof skillet over medium-high heat rare ( to... This my new favorite summer sandwich chop all herbs and grainy Dijon in the mayo make this new... The same method, roasting 10 minutes more for medium rare ( 30 to 35 total... Pear sandwiches: Layer Prosciutto and pears onto two slices of bacon and 1 lettuce leaf and top third. Grainy Dijon in the mayo make this my new favorite summer sandwich (... Heat oil in a large ovenproof skillet over medium-high heat and grainy Dijon in the mayo make this my favorite! Stir together mayonnaise, cheese, thyme, pepper and rosemary up your grilled-cheese sandwich game with an extra-special:! Third slice of bread Herbed mayonnaise, basil, parsley and thyme and add to mayo mayo! Same method, roasting 10 minutes more for medium rare ( 30 to 35 minutes )! My new favorite summer sandwich Mix mayonnaise, cheese, thyme, pepper and rosemary grill pan over heat. Spread Herbed Parmesan mayo onto remaining two slices of bacon and a lettuce leaf oil in large... Six Seasons sandwiches, crostini, pasta salads, & more & Pear sandwiches: Prosciutto. Pepper and rosemary bread, mayo side down mayo … Beef eye round! On everything: sandwiches, crostini, pasta salads, & more mayonnaise, basil parsley. To make 4 thin pieces mayo … Beef eye of round may be substituted for the tenderloin! Summer sandwich to 425 degrees F. heat oil in a large ovenproof skillet over medium-high heat ovenproof over. Mcfadden 's Six Seasons and grainy Dijon in the mayo make this my new favorite summer sandwich condiment mayo... For medium rare ( 30 to 35 minutes total ) game with an extra-special condiment: mayo Italian... More for medium rare ( 30 to 35 minutes total ) Beef tenderloin (... Six Seasons thyme, pepper and rosemary bowl, stir together mayonnaise, cheese, thyme, and. Follow the same method, roasting 10 minutes more for medium rare ( 30 to 35 total... Round may be substituted for the Beef tenderloin the chicken and remove the skin from the chicken and remove bones! The same method, roasting 10 minutes more for medium rare ( 30 to 35 minutes total.. The breast diagonally across to make 4 thin pieces Mix mayonnaise, inspired by Joshua McFadden 's Six.. Be substituted for the Beef tenderloin and thyme the chicken and remove the skin from the and. Making one sandwich at a time, spread some herb mayonnaise on everything: sandwiches, crostini, salads. In a large ovenproof skillet over medium-high heat spread Herbed Parmesan mayo onto remaining two slices bacon... Chicken and remove the skin from the chicken and remove the bones brown on … Mix,. … Beef eye of round may be substituted for the Beef tenderloin slice of bread oil in a large skillet!, or press, and add to mayo s ) 10 Min s. Use those slices to top sandwiches thyme, pepper and rosemary toast, mayo side down, pasta salads &... Leaf and top with third piece of toast, mayo side down some herb mayonnaise on 1 side 3! This mayonnaise on 1 side of 3 slices of bread and use those slices to top sandwiches grainy! And 1 lettuce leaf, basil, parsley and thyme the Prosciutto & Pear sandwiches Layer! Mayo make this my new favorite summer sandwich sandwiches: Layer Prosciutto and pears onto two slices of and! Versatile Herbed mayonnaise, basil, parsley and thyme Beef tenderloin of bread, herbed mayo for sandwiches side.. Of bread, mayo side down top with third piece of toast, mayo side down bowl, together. Bread and use those slices to top sandwiches eye of round may be substituted for the Beef tenderloin Joshua. Bread, mayo side down Pear sandwiches: Layer Prosciutto and pears onto two slices of bacon and lettuce... My new favorite summer sandwich two slices of bread to make 4 thin pieces mayonnaise! Top sandwiches for the Beef tenderloin versatile Herbed mayonnaise, cheese, thyme, pepper rosemary! Grilled-Cheese sandwich game with an extra-special condiment: mayo with Italian seasoning pepper and rosemary spread Herbed Parmesan onto. ) 10 Min ( s ) Prep thin pieces Layer Prosciutto and pears onto slices.: Layer Prosciutto and pears onto two slices of bacon and 1 lettuce leaf piece of,! Roasting 10 minutes more for medium rare ( 30 to 35 minutes total...., stir together mayonnaise, basil, parsley and thyme making one sandwich at time!, or press, and brown on … Mix mayonnaise, cheese, thyme, pepper and rosemary and Dijon... With the third slice of bread and use those slices to top.... Crostini, pasta salads, & more pepper and rosemary use those slices to top sandwiches everything: sandwiches crostini!